You are currently viewing Employee vs Contractor: ATO Tax Implications

Employee vs Contractor: ATO Tax Implications

Navigating the world of taxes can be a daunting task, especially when it comes to understanding the distinctions between employees and independent contractors. As a business owner or a worker, the question of “employee vs independent contractor taxes” can have far-reaching consequences. It’s not just about filling out the right forms or meeting deadlines; it’s about getting it right from the start to ensure compliance with the Australian Taxation Office (ATO) regulations.

In this blog, we will delve into the implications of being classified as an employee or a contractor in Australia. We’ll shed light on the key differences between these classifications and how they impact your tax obligations.

So, let’s dive into the details without further adieu.

ATO’s New Guidelines for Employee vs. Contractor Classification

In February 2022, the High Court delivered two landmark judgments that prompted the Australian Taxation Office (ATO) to release new guidelines on distinguishing between employees and independent contractors. These updated guidelines carry significant implications for employers and businesses. Understanding the key factors that differentiate employees from contractors is now more crucial than ever to ensure compliance with ATO regulations.

New Guidelines Based on Contractual Terms

The ATO’s new guidelines focus on contractual terms to classify workers as employees or independent contractors. Businesses must have clear contracts outlining work arrangements, and if the actual work aligns with the contract, the ATO recognizes the classification.

If the contract isn’t genuinely followed, additional factors may be considered. These additional factors could include—

  • when the contract was established,
  • any subsequent agreements,
  • or whether the contract was merely a sham to disguise an employment relationship.

Having accurate contracts is crucial to determine the worker’s status and avoid tax and legal issues.

Factors Considered by ATO Based on the Tax Implications for the Independent Contractor vs Employee

The ATO considers several factors to fix if a worker falls into the category of an employee or an independent contractor. These factors include:

Ability to Delegate

The ATO examines whether the worker can delegate tasks to others or is required to perform the work personally.

Level of Control

The level of control exercised by the business over the worker’s tasks and work methods is taken into account.

Tools and Equipment

The ATO assesses who provides the tools and equipment necessary for the job.

Level of Risk

The extent of commercial risk undertaken by the worker, such as liability for defects in the work, is considered.

Ability to Generate Goodwill

The ATO evaluates whether the worker has the potential to generate goodwill or establish their own business identity.


The ATO looks at whether the worker represents the business as an integral part of it or operates independently.

Plus, for employers, it is essential to review their contractor agreements thoroughly. All terms and conditions should be clearly outlined in writing to avoid ambiguity. Relying solely on checklists for worker classification is discouraged; instead, a comprehensive review of the actual working relationship should be conducted.

Now, let’s move into a detailed overview of the question, “What’s the difference between a contract and full-time employment?”

Who is an Employee?

An employee is a person who works for another person or organization (the employer) in return for payment. As for how to pay employee taxes, employees are typically paid a salary or wage, and the employer withholds income tax, superannuation, and other taxes from their pay. Employees are also entitled to a number of benefits, such as sick leave, annual leave, and parental leave.

Who is an Individual Contractor?

Now, let’s move on to define a contractor. An individual contractor, by the self-employed definition, is a person who contracts to provide services to another party. Individual contractors are responsible for their own taxes and benefits, and they are not entitled to any benefits from their clients.

Independent contractors are essentially considered as operating their own small businesses, which results in several tax implications. These implications include the responsibility of managing their own GST registration and payments.

Additionally, independent contractors must handle their income tax payments themselves, as an employer does not deduct it as it would for traditional employees.

What is the Difference Between an Employee and Individual Contractor When It Comes to Tax?

The difference between permanent employee vs contractor when it comes to tax obligations is significant.

Tax Obligations: Employees vs. Contractors

When it comes to contractors’ superannuation, there is a notable difference between employees and independent contractors. Employees have taxes deducted from their salary, and their employer is responsible for making compulsory superannuation contributions on their behalf. Plus, employers have to report and pay fringe benefits tax (FBT) if they provide their employees with fringe benefits.

In contrast, contractors are required to pay their own taxes from their gross earnings and make their own superannuation contributions. Employers typically don’t withhold tax from payments to contractors, but they may do so if the contractor does not provide an ABN or if there is a voluntary agreement between the employer and the contractor to withhold tax. 

However, employers may still have to pay super for individual contractors if the contract is principally for their labour. Plus, employers do not have FBT obligations for independent contractors.

All the above provide a glimpse of the independent contractor vs employee tax differences.

Importance of Correct Classification

The responsibility of correctly classifying workers falls on the hiring business. If a worker is wrongly categorized as a contractor when they should be considered an employee, the business could face serious consequences. If a worker is an employee employers need to:

  • withhold Pay-As-You-Go (PAYG) withholding tax on the worker’s wages, and
  • pay super, at least quarterly, for eligible employees 

Consequences of Misclassification

The Fair Work Act prohibits “sham contracting arrangements,” where employers misclassify workers as independent contractors to avoid providing employee entitlements. This practice is illegal and can lead to prosecution for tax evasion and penalties for violating superannuation and workers’ compensation laws.

Implications for Businesses

From an accounting perspective, the ATO’s updated guidelines have implications for businesses. Proper classification of workers ensures compliance with tax laws. If a worker is considered an employee, the business must handle PAYG withholding tax, superannuation contributions, and other employment-related expenses. In contrast, if a worker is an independent contractor, these obligations do not apply, but the contractor assumes responsibility for their taxes and insurance.

Ensuring Correct Classification

To avoid tax liabilities and penalties, it is crucial for businesses to classify their workers accurately. Using clear and accurate contractor agreements that reflect the true nature of the working relationship is essential. Seeking professional advice can help ensure compliance with the legislation and prevent any potential tax issues.

Tax Rates for Independent Contractors vs Employees

The income tax rates for independent contractors and employees in Australia are the same. The Australian Taxation Office (ATO) has a progressive tax system, which means that the more you earn, the higher the percentage of your income you pay in tax. 

In the 2023-24 tax year, Australian residents’ tax rates are as follows:

  • Income up to $18,200: Nil tax
  • $18,201 – $45,000: 19 cents for each $1 over $18,200
  • $45,001 – $120,000: $5,092 plus 32.5 cents for each $1 over $45,000
  • $120,001 – $180,000: $29,467 plus 37 cents for each $1 over $120,000
  • $180,001 and over: $51,667 plus 45 cents for each $1 over $180,000

Please note that the above rates do not include the Medicare levy of 2%.

Are you searching for reliable and hassle-free taxation services? Look no further than Seed Plus – your trusted business partner and contributor to your growth! We specialize in various tax returns, including Individual, Business/Company, Partnerships, and Family Trust Tax Returns. 

Our comprehensive services also encompass small business advice, bookkeeping, and BAS and IAS preparation and lodgment. Let us handle your tax returns with efficiency and accuracy while ensuring you comply with all taxation regulations. 

Contact us today to discuss your needs or explore our pre-designed Tax Return Packages for 2022-2023!

Wrapping Up

To sum up, the distinction between employee vs independent contractor taxes holds significant implications. Accurate classification is essential to meet tax obligations and avoid potential consequences. Businesses must adhere to the ATO’s updated guidelines, review contracts, and seek professional advice for a compliant and successful operation. Understanding these tax implications paves the way for a smooth and prosperous business journey.


What are the employee vs. independent contractor tax benefits?

The employee contractor tax impact is distinct, with employees having their taxes withheld by their employer and are entitled to benefits such as sick leave and annual leave. On the other hand, independent contractors are responsible for paying their own taxes but can deduct business expenses and have more flexibility.

What is the main difference between a consultant and a contractor?

A consultant is a professional providing expert advice or specialized services, while a contractor is typically engaged to complete a specific task or project.

Do sole traders need workers’ compensation?

Sole traders are not required to have workers’ compensation as they work for themselves and do not have employees. 

What is the difference between labour hire and contractors?

Labour hire involves hiring workers from an agency to perform tasks on behalf of the business, while contractors are self-employed individuals engaged in specific projects or services.

Join us via facebook:

Contact our office: (03) 6153 0180 to discuss your scenario.

There's more than one way to nurture your business.

Contact us to Discuss your Business Needs to understand how we can help you achieve more.

Primary contact number

Leave a Reply